$1,800,000 Active
3504 Pony Express Road
South Lake Tahoe, CA 96150

Get homes like this by email

When a home like this lists in South Lake Tahoe at a similar price and size, we email you the same day. No account needed.

See all 223 homes for sale in South Lake Tahoe →
⏳ STR — New Permits Waitlisted
City of South Lake Tahoe VHR permit required — the city's 900-permit residential cap was reached on August 21, 2026; new applications outside the Tourist Core are waitlisted. There is no guarantee a new owner will obtain a permit, and permits do NOT transfer on sale. Do not count on rental income without a permit in hand.
5 Beds
·
3.0 Baths
·
3,292 Sq Ft

Our data on this home

About This Property

Discover the perfect blend of mountain living, privacy, and entertaining at this beautiful 5-bedroom,3.5-bathroom home tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac. Situated on an impressive 16,553-square-foot lot, this property backs directly to Forest Service land, offering exceptional privacy, peaceful surroundings, and endless opportunities to explore the outdoors right from your backyard. With the potential to ski home from Heavenly Mountain Resort, this is a truly special Tahoe setting!Designed for gathering and entertaining, the home features an inviting upstairs living area with a wall of windows to take in the mountain views. The great room is enhanced by a vaulted ceiling and a gas fireplace that creates a warm mountain atmosphere, while custom built-in bookshelves add character and charm to both the living and dining areas. The pool table is included, making this an ideal space for entertaining family and friends.The open-concept floor plan flows effortlessly into a generously sized kitchen featuring granite countertops, ample workspace, and pantry.Step outside from the living room onto a large redwood deck, perfect for outdoor dining, entertaining, or simply enjoying the fresh mountain air. A bridge leads up the hillside to an additional patio, creating a unique and peaceful retreat. It's the perfect spot to unwind, enjoy your favorite beverage, and take in the mountain and forest views. The primary suite on the upper level includes a walk in closet and spacious bath with separate jetted tub and shower.The lower level offers additional living flexibility with a separate living area, an office featuring French doors opening directly off the living space. In addition there is a laundry area, and additional bedrooms. The suite off the garage offers even more possibilities and can be locked off from the remainder of the lower level, providing a flexible arrangement for guests, extended family, or additional private living space.With five bedrooms, three and a half bathrooms, and a spacious three-car garage, there's plenty of room for family, guests, and all your Tahoe toys.Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, a mountain getaway, or a place to create lasting family memories, 3504 Pony Express Road offers a rare combination of space, privacy, outdoor access, and classic Tahoe lifestyle. Enjoy the peace and quiet of this exceptional setting while remaining close to everything Lake Tahoe has to offer.Buyer to conduct their own due diligence regarding all permits, additions, improvements, and property details.

Listed by Michelle Blue-Benedict — Berkshire Hathaway Home Services Drysdale Properties - South Lake Tahoe

Listing Details

Status Active
MLS # 143625
Days on Market 1
Price/Sq Ft $547

Property History

Nov 09, 2026
Listed for sale
$1,800,000

Sale History · changed hands 1×

Sold Price Listing agent (sell side) Buyer agent (buy side)
Dec 2014 · county record $937,500 Deed record — brokerage sides not reported

MLS closed sales, with duplicate ingestions collapsed and lease records excluded, so each row is a distinct transaction. Rows marked county record come from the assessor's deed data, which reaches back further than the MLS feed; rows marked via a listing site fill the years the feed misses using that site's public sale record.

Property Overview
Beds 5
Baths 3.0
Sq. Ft. 3,292
Lot Size 0.38 acres
Year Built 2015
Property Type Single Family Residence
Style Contemporary
Subdivision Unavail
County El Dorado
STR Jurisdiction South Lake Tahoe
APN 025670034000
Parking
Garage Spaces 3
Parking Features Garage Door Opener
Attached Garage Yes
Exterior & Lot
Lot Features Cul-De-Sac, Adjacent to Forest
View Mountains, Forest
Construction Wood Frame, Wood Siding
Roof Pitched, Composition
Foundation Concrete/Crawl Space
Utilities & Systems
Heating Forced Air, Natural Gas
📊

STR Investment Analysis

See projected rental revenue, occupancy rates, and investment scores.

STR Investment Analysis

Red Zone
STRUCTURAL SCORE Premium
73
No revenue projection. Short-term rental permits are not currently obtainable here — the local jurisdiction has reached its permit cap or is waitlisting all new applications.

STR Investment Summary — 3504 Pony Express Road, South Lake Tahoe

No revenue projection. Short-term rental permits are not currently obtainable here — the local jurisdiction has reached its permit cap or is waitlisting all new applications.
Structural Score: 73 / 100 (Premium) · STR Zone: Red

Land Coverage (TRPA)

Tahoe Regional Planning Agency impervious-coverage budget for this parcel

Room to build
3,204 sq ft covered of 3,252 sq ft allowed
48 sq ft of coverage still available to add.
Parcel Size
16,280 sq ft
Allowed Coverage · est.
3,252 sq ft · 20%
Existing Coverage · est.
3,204 sq ft · 20%
Addable Coverage
48 sq ft
IPES Score
852.0
Land Capability · TRPA-verified
IPES
Existing Units
1

TRPA caps how much of each Tahoe Basin parcel can be covered by impervious surfaces — buildings, driveways, decks. Existing coverage is TRPA's satellite estimate; allowed coverage uses TRPA's verified land class when one is on file, otherwise TRPA's estimate — data: TRPA GIS / Tahoe Open Data, LT Info. The only authoritative determination of coverage and land capability is a Land Capability Verification through TRPA; actual allowable coverage can differ due to verifications, transfers, banked coverage, or deed restrictions.

TRPA parcel fact sheet ↗ How the Basin compares

Home Insurance Estimate

California FAIR Plan fire policy + a DIC wrap policy, the usual Tahoe setup

$7,700 – $9,000/yr
about $696/mo
Est. Rebuild Cost (Coverage A)
$1,382,640
FAIR Plan (fire)
$6,400/yr
DIC wrap (theft, water, liability)
$1,300 – $2,600/yr

Estimate from this ZIP's California FAIR Plan rates (Plan data as of 6/30/2026, with the 29.1% increase effective 10/15/2026) on an estimated rebuild cost, plus a DIC policy at 20–40% of the FAIR premium. Not a bindable quote; a local broker quote depends on the home's age, roof, defensible space and claims history.

See it in the monthly payment Tahoe wildfire insurance costs

Cost Segregation Tax Savings

Estimated first-year bonus depreciation savings

Estimated First-Year Tax Savings
$0
via bonus depreciation
Land Value
$0
Improvement Basis
$0
5-Year Property (18%)
$0
15-Year Property (10%)
$0
Estimates are for informational purposes only and do not constitute tax advice. Consult a qualified CPA or tax professional for your specific situation. Actual savings depend on individual tax circumstances.

Payment calculator

$11,440 per month
Principal & interest
$9,102/mo
Property taxes
$1,642/mo
1.0946% of the price, El Dorado County's 2025-26 rate, plus direct charges: California re-assesses a home at its sale price.
HOA dues
$0/mo
From MLS listing data.
Home insurance
$696/mo
CA FAIR Plan + DIC estimate, ~$7,700–$9,000/yr — wildfire-zone rates vary; not a bindable quote.
Down payment
20% ($360,000)
Home price
$1,800,000
Loan details
30-yr fixed, 6.5%
Request a Tour

We'll contact you soon.

R
Real Estate Tahoe
Real Estate Agent

Send a Message