$1,099,000 $1,249,000 ↓ $150,000 reduced Active
1251 Margaret Avenue
South Lake Tahoe, CA 96150
✓ STR Allowed — Permit Required
City of South Lake Tahoe requires a Vacation Home Rental (VHR) permit — capped at roughly 900 permits citywide (residential zones), so availability varies. Verify current permit availability before counting on rental income.
3 Beds
·
2.5 Baths
·
1,825 Sq Ft
Virtual Tour

About This Property

Completed in late 2023 by respected local builder Paul McGill, this meticulously crafted modern mountain home offers a rare combination of new construction, smart-home features, and effortless ownership within South Lake Tahoe City limits. Designed for today's lifestyle, the home delivers energy efficiency, quality craftsmanship, and low-maintenance living in one of South Lake Tahoe's most evolving residential areas.Clean architectural lines, vaulted ceilings, and a mountain contemporary design create a bright, open feel throughout. Negotiable curated furnishings and kitchenware from Pottery Barn, custom window dressings, and linens make the home feel immediately welcoming, for a smooth transition into ownership.Built with defensible space features and a passing certificate to support insurance requirements, this property reflects thoughtful planning for mountain living. A Generac generator provides dependable backup power, and the attached 2-car garage easily accommodates larger vehicles, ideal for year-round Tahoe access. Perfectly positioned next to a wooded vacant lot, the fully fenced yard with a custom privacy fence creating an ideal space for pets, children, entertaining, and relaxed outdoor living.Located in the up-and-coming neighborhood known as "The Y,'' the area continues to gain momentum with new local shops, improved amenities, and direct access to outdoor recreation. From the doorstep, enjoy nearby trail systems and an easy E-bike ride to Lake Tahoe and Kiva Beach, blending convenience with the best of Tahoe's natural setting.Set in a convenient South Lake Tahoe location, the home offers a quieter mountain setting during peak ski season while still being just minutes from Heavenly Mountain Resort.This allows for quick, easy access to the slopes without being in the center of resort traffic. An ideal balance of access and retreat, where ski days are effortless and home feels peaceful upon return.Surrounded by year-round recreation including skiing, hiking, biking, and lake activities, this property delivers a true Tahoe lifestyle. Enjoy the benefits of newer construction without the wait times, contractor coordination, renovation costs, or uncertainty often associated with older mountain properties.A rare opportunity combining elevated design in one exceptional Tahoe home positioned to enjoy nature while remaining close to favorite local coffee shops, breweries, bakeries, pizza spots, rock climbing gym, and the lake.

Listed by Jessica Crase — Compass

Listing Details

Status Active
MLS # 142635
Days on Market 139
Sold Date 1800-01-01
Price/Sq Ft $602

Property History

Mar 26, 2026
Listed for sale
$1,099,000
Jul 15, 2026
Price changed
$1,099,000

Sale History · changed hands 1×

Sold Price Listing agent (sell side) Buyer agent (buy side)
Nov 2023 $875,000 Mark SalmonCompass Jessica M CraseCompass

MLS closed sales, with duplicate ingestions collapsed and lease records excluded, so each row is a distinct transaction. Rows marked county record come from the assessor's deed data, which reaches back further than the MLS feed.

Property Overview
Beds 3
Baths 2.5
Sq. Ft. 1,825
Lot Size 0.12 acres
Year Built 2023
Property Type Single Family Residence
Style Contemporary
Subdivision Unavail
County El Dorado
STR Jurisdiction South Lake Tahoe
APN 032282017000
Parking
Garage Spaces 2
Parking Features Garage Door Opener
Attached Garage Yes
Exterior & Lot
Construction Wood Frame, Wood Siding
Roof Composition
Foundation Concrete/Crawl Space
Utilities & Systems
Heating Forced Air, Natural Gas, Electric, Fireplace
📊

STR Investment Analysis

See projected rental revenue, occupancy rates, and investment scores.

STR Investment Analysis

Permitted Zone
STRUCTURAL SCORE Excellent
87
PROJECTED ANNUAL REVENUE
$142,500 ($118K – $167K range)
~$11,875 per month
Avg Nightly
$485
Occupancy
68%
Cap Rate
5.2%

STR Investment Summary — 1251 Margaret Avenue, South Lake Tahoe

Est. Annual Revenue
$48,849
Avg Nightly Rate
$268
Projected Occupancy
49.8%
Cap Rate
1.8%
Structural Score: 77 / 100 (Luxury) · STR Zone: Yellow

Based on comparable vacation rental performance data for South Lake Tahoe. Revenue projections are estimates and may vary.

Land Coverage (TRPA)

Tahoe Regional Planning Agency impervious-coverage budget for this parcel

Room to build
181 sq ft covered of 1,254 sq ft allowed
1,073 sq ft of coverage still available to add.
Parcel Size
5,015 sq ft
Allowed Coverage
1,254 sq ft · 25%
Existing Coverage
181 sq ft · 4%
Addable Coverage
1,073 sq ft
IPES Score
871.0
Land Capability · TRPA-verified
IPES

TRPA caps how much of each Tahoe Basin parcel can be covered by impervious surfaces — buildings, driveways, decks. Estimated coverage — data: TRPA GIS / Tahoe Open Data. The only authoritative determination of coverage and land capability is a Land Capability Verification through TRPA; actual allowable coverage can differ due to verifications, transfers, banked coverage, or deed restrictions.

TRPA parcel fact sheet ↗

Cost Segregation Tax Savings

Estimated first-year bonus depreciation savings

Estimated First-Year Tax Savings
$0
via bonus depreciation
Land Value
$0
Improvement Basis
$0
5-Year Property (18%)
$0
15-Year Property (10%)
$0
Estimates are for informational purposes only and do not constitute tax advice. Consult a qualified CPA or tax professional for your specific situation. Actual savings depend on individual tax circumstances.

Payment calculator

$0 per month
Principal & interest
$0
Property taxes
$0
HOA dues
$0
From MLS listing data.
Home insurance
$0
Insurance estimate only — Tahoe wildfire-zone rates vary; get a local broker quote for accuracy.
Down payment
20% ($219,800)
Home price
$1,099,000
Loan details
30-yr fixed, 6.5%
Request a Tour

We'll contact you soon.

R
Real Estate Tahoe
Real Estate Agent

Send a Message