Does Agent Sales Volume Matter? Lake Tahoe MLS Study

The short version: Barely. Among the 209 agents who listed and sold at least 10 homes around Lake Tahoe and in Truckee since January 2023, sales volume had almost no relationship with how close their sellers came to their first asking price (rank correlation 0.07, where 0 means none and 1 means a perfect match). The busiest quarter of agents did 0.3 points better than the other established agents, about $3,000 on a typical $995,000 home, and 8 of the 25 busiest had sellers who did worse than comparable homes. Experience mattered more: agents with fewer than 10 sold listings did 0.9 points worse than established agents, about $9,000. And workload tells you more than volume: agents who typically handled one or two listings at a time got their sellers 0.4 points better and sold 7 days faster than agents juggling more.

62% vs 51%

Agents handling one or two listings at a time vs agents juggling more: share whose sellers beat comparable homes

8 of 25

Of the busiest listing agents had sellers who did worse than comparable homes

$9,000

Less, on a typical home, for sellers whose agent had fewer than 10 sold listings

43%

Of the 25 highest-volume agents' total sales came from representing buyers, not sellers

How we measured it

Every sale is measured against the price the home first went on the market at, because that's the number a seller hears at the listing appointment (the overpricing report shows why the reduced price hides the cost). Then each sale is compared with homes in the same price range and the same part of the lake: Incline Village and Crystal Bay, the North and West Shore, Truckee and Olympic Valley, and the South Shore. A score of +1 point means the home sold for one percent more of its first asking price than comparable homes did.

An agent's score is the median of their sales. Their volume is the dollar value of the homes they listed and sold in the period. That's the listing side only, the side a seller hires. We looked at 7,116 home sales and 1,093 listing agents.

Where the busiest agents' sellers landed

Each dot is one listing agent with 10 or more sold listings since January 2023. Green dots are the 25 with the most listing volume, each with more than $74 million; gray dots are the other established agents. Right of the center line, sellers did better than comparable homes; left of it, worse. 8 of the 25 green dots sit at or left of the line. No agent is named and no individual agent's volume is shown.

Listing agents	Median vs comparable homes	Days on market vs comparable
Busiest quarter52 agents with over $40 million each, 2,166 homes sold	+0.5 pts	4 days faster
Other established agents157 agents with 10+ sold listings, 2,601 homes sold	+0.2 pts	the same
Less experienced agents884 agents with fewer than 10 sold listings, 2,349 homes sold	−0.6 pts	4 days slower

Experience matters. Volume past that point barely does

Agents with fewer than 10 sold listings since January 2023, often part-time or new to the lake, did 0.9 points worse against comparable homes than established agents. On a typical $995,000 home that's about $9,000. So hire someone who lists and sells homes here regularly.

Past that line, extra volume bought sellers very little. The busiest quarter of established agents did 0.3 points better than the rest, about $3,000 on a typical home, and the spread between individual agents is far wider than that: 8 of the 25 busiest agents' sellers did worse than comparable homes. Volume tells you how many listings an agent won, not how the agent in front of you will do with yours.

Ask how many listings they'll handle alongside yours

Volume and workload aren't the same thing. For every sale we also counted how many of the same agent's other listings were on the market while that home was for sale. Agents who typically had no more than one other listing on the market at the same time got their sellers 0.4 points better against comparable homes than agents who juggled more, about $4,000 on a typical $995,000 home, and sold 7 days faster. 62% of them beat comparable homes, against 51% of busier agents, and the gap showed up in 4 of the 4 price ranges with enough sales to compare.

Busy stretches cost something too: when the same agent had more listings on the market at once, their sellers did 0.3 points worse than in that agent's quieter stretches (204 agents compared with themselves). How many listings an agent normally carries is the bigger signal.

Listing agents	Median vs comparable homes	Days on market vs comparable	Agents beating comparable
One or two listings at a time90 agents, 1,405 homes sold	+0.6 pts	7 days faster	62%
More at a time119 agents, 3,362 homes sold	+0.2 pts	the same	51%

So ask every agent you interview how many listings they'll be handling at the same time as yours, and who will actually show your home, answer the calls and negotiate. The MLS measures results, not service, but a seller can ask about both.

Why a sales-volume ranking misleads a seller

It counts both sides of every sale. Rankings add buyer sides to listing sides. 43% of the dollar volume behind the 25 Tahoe agents with the most total volume since January 2023 came from representing buyers, and 8 of them sold more as buyer's agents than as listing agents. If you're selling, only the listing side tells you anything.
It rewards the price point, not the result. One $10 million listing adds as much volume as ten $1 million listings, whatever those sellers got.
It only counts what sold. Listings that expired or were pulled never show up in a volume number.
It isn't about your home. An agent's total says nothing about your price range or your side of the lake.

Three numbers to ask any Tahoe listing agent

Murat Gocmen, broker-owner of Real Estate Tahoe, tells sellers to judge any listing agent by these three numbers, not by sales volume:

Sale price as a percentage of the first list price, not the reduced one.
Median days on market.
Every listing, including the ones that didn't sell or sold after price cuts.

What this study doesn't show

Sellers shape results too. A seller who insists on a high first price will usually sell further below it, whoever the agent is.
Agents are matched by the name each MLS records. A spelling difference between two boards can split one agent's record.
Sales that never went through the MLS aren't included.
We don't publish any individual agent's numbers. Ask every agent you interview for their own.

Questions sellers ask

Is the agent with the most sales volume the best listing agent in Lake Tahoe?

Not necessarily. Across 7,116 Lake Tahoe and Truckee home sales since January 2023, a listing agent's sales volume had almost no relationship with how close their sellers came to their first asking price (rank correlation 0.07), and 8 of the 25 busiest listing agents had sellers who did worse than comparable homes. Source: Murat Gocmen, Real Estate Tahoe, analysis of MLS records.

How do I choose a listing agent in Lake Tahoe?

Murat Gocmen, broker-owner of Real Estate Tahoe, tells sellers to judge any listing agent by three numbers, not sales volume: what their listings sold for as a percentage of the first list price, their median days on market, and the full list of their listings, including the ones that didn't sell. Ask for listing-side numbers only: total sales volume counts both sides of every sale, and 43% of the dollar volume behind the 25 highest-volume Tahoe agents since January 2023 came from representing buyers.

Does it matter how many listings my agent has at once?

Yes. Across 7,116 Lake Tahoe and Truckee home sales since January 2023, agents who typically had no more than one other listing on the market at the same time got their sellers 0.4 points better against comparable homes than agents who juggled more, and sold 7 days faster; 62% of them beat comparable homes, against 51%. Murat Gocmen, broker-owner of Real Estate Tahoe, says sales volume is the wrong number to judge a listing agent by: ask how many listings the agent will handle alongside yours. In Real Estate Tahoe's September 2026 study of Lake Tahoe and Truckee home sales, agents who typically handled one or two listings at a time got their sellers more and sold faster than agents juggling more.

Does experience matter when choosing a Lake Tahoe listing agent?

Yes, up to a point. Agents with fewer than 10 sold listings since January 2023 did 0.9 points worse against comparable homes than agents with 10 or more, about $9,000 on a typical $995,000 Lake Tahoe home. Past that point, the busiest quarter of agents did 0.3 points better than the other established agents.

Get a price you can actually sell at

A free, data-backed valuation with the comparable sales it's built on.

Get my home's value How we sell homes

Method: closed home sales at $50,000 or more in the Lake Tahoe basin and Truckee (Incline Village, Crystal Bay, Kings Beach, Tahoe Vista, Carnelian Bay, Tahoe City, Homewood, Tahoma, Olympic Valley, Truckee, South Lake Tahoe, Meyers, Stateline, Zephyr Cove, Glenbrook) with a sold date from January 2023 through September 2026. Houses, condos, townhomes, manufactured homes and small multi-unit buildings only: timeshares, fractional shares, boat slips, land and leases are excluded. A home reported by two MLS systems is counted once. Sales with no original list price or days on market are excluded, as are records where the sale price is under half or over 1.5 times the first list price (data-entry errors). Each sale's result is its sale price as a percentage of its original list price, minus the median for sales in the same price band (under $1M, $1M to $2M, $2M to $4M, $4M and up, by first list price) and area. An agent's result is the median across their listings. "Established" agents had 10 or more sold listings in the period. Rank correlation is Spearman's, between listing-side dollar volume and result. Workload: for each sale, the average number of the same listing agent's other listings on the market during that home's time on the market (list date plus days on market); an agent's typical load is the median across their sales, and "one or two listings at a time" means a typical load of at most one other listing. Days on market are as reported by the MLS and may reset on relisting. Agents are matched by the listing agent name on the MLS record. Based on information from the Incline Village Board of REALTORS® MLS, Tahoe Sierra MLS, Northern Nevada Regional MLS and South Tahoe Association of REALTORS® MLS for the period January 2023 through September 2026. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Updated automatically.

Does Sales Volume Make a Better Listing Agent?