840 Modesto Avenue #1, South Lake Tahoe, CA
4 beds · 1,212 sq ft · $552 a sq ft · about $4,256 a month
Our data on this home
Answers other sites don't give you
-
Can it be a short-term rental?
SLT STR permits waitlisted
City of South Lake Tahoe VHR permit required — the city's 900-permit residential cap was reached on August 21, 2026; new applications outside the Tourist Core are waitlisted. There is no guarantee a new owner will obtain a permit, and permits do NOT transfer on sale. Do not count on rental income without a permit in hand.
The rental rules and our estimate -
What would it earn as a rental?
No projection
Permit or HOA rules block it — see why.
How we estimate it -
Can you add on to it?
Est. above allowance
TRPA's maps estimate 2,709 sq ft of land coverage on this lot and an allowance of 1,802 sq ft. Both are estimates, not a ruling. Ask us before you plan a deck, garage or addition.
What land coverage means -
What does insurance cost?
$2,900 – $3,400 a year
FAIR Plan + DIC wrap, the usual Tahoe setup, about $262 a month, from an estimated rebuild cost of $509,040. Not a bindable quote.
Get a real quote
About this home
Recently updated South Lake Tahoe duplex with 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and 1,212 square feet of living space. Both units have been thoughtfully updated with new stainless steel appliances, gas stoves, soft-close cabinetry, new LVT flooring, and new washers and dryers. Ceiling fans are installed throughout, and the property is equipped with a Ring security system for added convenience and peace of mind. Apartment one also features a new furnace and hot water heater. Each unit offers its own rear deck, providing dedicated outdoor space, while the two-car garage provides covered parking and additional storage. The property comes fully furnished and has an excellent rental history, making it an appealing opportunity for both investors and those looking for a Tahoe property with income potential. The adjacent vacant lot is owned by the Tahoe Conservancy. Conveniently located within walking distance of Reagan Beach, shopping, and restaurants, with Heavenly Ski Resort just minutes away. This property offers immediate usability, established rental potential, and a prime South Lake Tahoe location. Come see it today!
Listed by Jackie Arthur — Compass · MLS# 143556
- Status
- Active
- MLS #
- 143556
- Days on Market
- 47
- Price/Sq Ft
- $552
Email me if this home's price drops or it goes under contract
We email you the day 840 Modesto Avenue #1 drops its price, goes under contract or sells, plus new homes like it in South Lake Tahoe at a similar price and size. No account needed.
What it costs to own
- Principal and interest
- $3,383
- Property taxes1.0946% of the price, El Dorado County's 2025-26 rate, plus direct charges: California re-assesses a home at its sale price.
- $610
- Home insurance, our estimateCA FAIR Plan + DIC estimate, ~$2,900–$3,400/yr — wildfire-zone rates vary; not a bindable quote.
- $263
If you rent it: estimated first-year tax savings of $49,952 through bonus depreciation (cost segregation, 37% bracket). An estimate, not tax advice; ask your CPA. See the math
Payment calculator: change the down payment, price and rate
Payment calculator
Cost segregation tax savings, with your tax bracket
Cost Segregation Tax Savings
Estimated first-year bonus depreciation savings
Show calculation details
Estimates are for informational purposes only and do not constitute tax advice. Consult a qualified CPA or tax professional for your specific situation. Actual savings depend on individual tax circumstances.
Short-term rental
STR Investment Summary — 840 Modesto Avenue #1, South Lake Tahoe
No revenue projection. Short-term rental permits are not currently obtainable here — the local jurisdiction has reached its permit cap or is waitlisting all new applications.
Structural Score: 64 / 100 (Premium) · STR Zone: Red
Full rental analysis: monthly revenue, nightly rate, occupancy and risks
STR Investment Analysis
Red ZoneLand Coverage (TRPA)
Tahoe Regional Planning Agency impervious-coverage budget for this parcel
- 6,005 sq ftParcel Size
- 1,802 sq ft · 30%Allowed Coverage · est.
- 2,709 sq ft · 45%Existing Coverage · est.
- 0 sq ftAddable Coverage
- 2Existing Units
TRPA caps how much of each Tahoe Basin parcel can be covered by impervious surfaces — buildings, driveways, decks. Existing coverage is TRPA's satellite estimate; allowed coverage uses TRPA's verified land class when one is on file, otherwise TRPA's estimate — data: TRPA GIS / Tahoe Open Data, LT Info. The only authoritative determination of coverage and land capability is a Land Capability Verification through TRPA; actual allowable coverage can differ due to verifications, transfers, banked coverage, or deed restrictions.
Home Insurance Estimate
California FAIR Plan fire policy + a DIC wrap policy, the usual Tahoe setup
- $509,040Est. Rebuild Cost (Coverage A)
- $2,400/yrFAIR Plan (fire)
- $500 – $1,000/yrDIC wrap (theft, water, liability)
Estimate from this ZIP's California FAIR Plan rates (Plan data as of 6/30/2026, with the 29.1% increase effective 10/15/2026) on an estimated rebuild cost, plus a DIC policy at 20–40% of the FAIR premium. Not a bindable quote; a local broker quote depends on the home's age, roof, defensible space and claims history.
Price and sale history
Property History
- Oct 05, 2026 · Listed for sale $715,000
- Oct 21, 2026 · Price reduced $687,000 $715,000 ↓ $28,000
- Nov 06, 2026 · Price reduced $669,000 $687,000 ↓ $18,000
South Lake Tahoe by the numbers
- $675Kmedian sale price, last 90 days
- 68 daysmedian days on market, homes that sold
- 97%of list price, on average
- 3.7 monthsof supply at the last 90 days' pace
Similar Homes For Sale
-
Active
$665,0002567 Armstrong Avenue, South Lake Tahoe 4 bd · 2,048 sq ft -
Active
$625,000920 Lapham Drive, South Lake Tahoe 2 bd · 1,350 sq ft -
Active
$719,9002400 Tahoe Vista Drive #A & B, South Lake Tahoe 4 bd · 1,536 sq ft -
Active
$736,0003695 Primrose Road, South Lake Tahoe 5 bd · 2,116 sq ft -
Active
$795,0003357 Treehaven Drive, South Lake Tahoe 4 bd · 1,986 sq ft -
Active
$529,000746 Anita Drive, South Lake Tahoe 2 bd · 1,176 sq ft
Get homes like this by email
When a home like this lists in South Lake Tahoe at a similar price and size, we email you the same day. No account needed.
Nearby Properties
Market Trends in South Lake Tahoe (96150)
Monthly market report
How is the South Lake Tahoe market doing?
Sales, prices and days on market for South Lake Tahoe and every other Tahoe and Truckee neighborhood, from the MLS. The October 2026 PDF comes right away, then one email a month.
Browse South Lake Tahoe: South Lake Tahoe homes for sale · South Lake Tahoe condos for sale